Scott Exteriors is our pick for most homeowners. For those looking at FORTIFIED roofs, check out Smart Roof HP. Read our research and why we recommend them.
We like Scott Exteriors' industry-leading 5-year warranty on labor and retail amenities. Written bids are given on all of their work incase you need to submit it to insurance. Additionally, they're a true broker of roofing, and don't receive any kickbacks on products sold
Smart Roof and Home Performance offers Dallas-specific solutions for smart home and roof projects. They're leaders in class 4 shingle installation and energy efficient roofing installation.
“A 30-year shingle isn’t a 30-year shingle in Dallas.” because Dallas' extreme weather kills roofs.
Scott Exteriors is still our pick for all-around Dallas roofing. We like their ability to handle any roofing need — inspection, installation, and roof repair. They offer a strong blend of DFW neighborhood experience and competitive pricing.
Dallas homeowners who are willing to spend more for additional roof protection should choose Smart Roof and Home Performance. They offer industry-leading roof protection through the IBHS FORTIFIED program.
Here's what we'll cover in this updated guide to Dallas roofing contractors:
The data: HOMR handled 49 residential roofing projects for Dallas homeowners in 2023. We paired that service data with BBB reviews and external pricing data to create a basis to evaluate and rank the best Dallas-Fort Worth roofing services.
How we chose: We preferred contractors who focus on residential roofing, not commercial roof jobs. HOMR chose service providers that offer roof installation and roof repair services — we think Dallas homeowners need one point of contact for all their roofing projects.
Green flags and red flags: Your roofers should have extensive work history in Dallas and display familiarity with local concerns like hail, high winds and oak tree damage. Choose a service provider who is adept with various roofing materials and can furnish current license and insurance paperwork.
Popular Dallas roofing materials: Dallas residents choose asphalt shingles and Class 4 shingles more often than metal roofs and roofing tile. FORTIFIED roofing status offers enhanced protection against Dallas hail and severe wind events, and features potential tax and financial incentives.
Get a free quote on Dallas roofing installation and repair from both these companies through HOMR!
Sign up for HOMR → Receive a confirmation text from our team → Schedule your first spray → Manage everything in one place.
No contracts, no cancellation fees. Service is paid in advance - cancellation before full payment will result in a balance due of pest control treatment ONLY.
Join our newsletter
Get HomeExpert's recommendations, tips, cost guides and more sent straight to your inbox every week!
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
The Data & Research: Why You Should Trust Us
“We have extremely harsh weather conditions. Brutal heat, bitter cold, torrential rains, hail and high winds. Whatever you can throw at a roof, DFW does it.” Travis Jones, owner of SmartRoof HP, explained in his interview.
Last year, HOMR handled 49 residential roofing projects for our members. Roofing services for these jobs included new roof installation, full roof replacement, roof repair, and routine maintenance service calls.
We used member data and feedback from these roofing service calls to analyze some of Dallas' best roofers. We combined that information with publicly available Dallas residential roofing contractor data.
Here are several key variables we used to rate Dallas roofers:
Local Expertise. Does the service provider have a history of Dallas area roofing work? Do they have specific neighborhood expertise — North Dallas or Lake Highlands, for example?
Service Offerings. Does the provider have a specialty, like Dallas roof repair or inspection? Or do they provide a variety of service options?
Pricing Data. Does each Dallas roofer charge more, less, or about the same as their competitors for similar jobs?
License and Insurance Information. Is the roofing contractor properly licensed in Dallas and insured in the state of Texas?
Skip the contractor vetting process — HOMR already did it for you! Get a free quote on your roofing project with one message.
{{cta-component="/"}}
How We Selected Top Dallas Roofing Contractors
How did we narrow 4,000 Dallas roofing companies down to 2 HOMR featured partners? We put them through one of the most rigorous research and data processes in company history.
First, we eliminated Dallas area roofers that focused on commercial roofing. We found that most of these companies preferred commercial work and their residential customers suffered as a result.
Next, we focused on well-rounded roofing contractors. If a company specialized in roof repair or roof installation only, we eliminated them from consideration. HOMR prefers to recommend a roofing expert that can handle all your needs with one phone call.
We then eliminated any roofing company without a notable customer service reputation. We looked for an A+ rating with the BBB, a strong number of 5-star Google reviews, or both. We paired that with HOMR customer service data from recent roof inspection and service appointments we booked for our members.
Finally, we looked at pricing. We eliminated any providers with pricing far above current DFW market standards. We also removed “bargain basement” roofers from our search. The last place you want to cut corners is on the one thing that covers and protects your entire home and family.
Green Flags
✅ Lifelong Dallas Residents and Professionals
✅ Expertise With Various Roofing Materials
✅ Proper License and Insurance
✅ History of Repeat Neighborhood Service
✅ Quality Online Reviews
Red Flags
🚫 Vague Pricing Estimates
🚫 Unfamiliar with Specific Dallas Neighborhoods
🚫 Pricing Above or Below Market Standards
🚫 No Other Work Scheduled in Your Neighborhood
🚫 Commercial Roofing Experience Only
Dallas Roof Replacement Cost: It costs between $8,000 and $15,000 to replace a residential roof in Dallas. Learn the 4 key cost drivers of DFW roofing projects in our updated Cost Guide to Dallas roof replacement.
Our Picks for The Best Dallas Roofing Company
Meet Scott Exteriors for most homeowners with Asphalt shingle roofs, and Smart Roof & Home Performance for those that want additional protection.
We selected Scott Exteriors as the best all-around roofing provider in the greater Dallas area. Smart Roof and Home Performance is HOMR's pick for the most innovative Dallas roofing contractor.
🏆 Scott Exteriors: Best Overall Dallas Roofing Company
We selected Scott Exteriors for their wealth of experience and presence in multiple Dallas neighborhoods. They've operated out of Lake Highlands for nearly 30 years.
Why We Like Them: We value Scott Exteriors' wide range of service offerings. They offer new residential roof installation and roof repair, as well as siding and window options. They are a strong choice for Dallas homeowners with multiple exterior home project needs.
HOMR rates Scott Exteriors highly for their workmanship. They offer a 5-year workmanship warranty on residential roof replacements — at minimum. Scott Exteriors also carries liability insurance above and beyond Texas state requirements.
Non-Negotiables: Scott Exteriors has a visible, excellent customer service record. They are A+ rated with the Better Business Bureau, with no complaints, and have been accredited since 1997.
They are members of the North Texas Roofing and Contractors Association, National Roofing Contractors Association, and National Association of the Remodeling Industry.
🏆 Smart Roof and Home Performance: Most Innovative DFW Roofers
We selected Smart Roof and Home Performance for its commitment to technology and innovation. Their approach to roofing installation, materials and repairs is forward-thinking.
Why We Like Them: HOMR likes the company's whole-home approach. It allows Travis and his team to create energy-efficient and protective roofing with the rest of your house in mind.
Check back soon for an in-depth conversation with Smart Roof and Home Performance about FORTIFIED Roof, an enhanced roof protection trend that's gaining steam in DFW.
Non-Negotiables: Smart Roof and Home Performance goes out of its way to share knowledge with Dallas homeowners. They happily provide free information about industry trends and advancements in smart, energy efficient roofing technology.
We like Scott Exteriors' industry-leading 5-year warranty on labor and retail amenities. Written bids are given on all of their work incase you need to submit it to insurance. Additionally, they're a true broker of roofing, and don't receive any kickbacks on products sold
Smart Roof and Home Performance offers Dallas-specific solutions for smart home and roof projects. They're leaders in class 4 shingle installation and energy efficient roofing installation.
What roofing material should you choose for your Dallas area home? Here are the pros and cons of 4 roofing options, listed in order of popularity with Dallas homeowners:
“Roughly 85 percent of homes have composition shingles,” Scott Exteriors says. “If you’re in the market for a brand new roof, there’s a good chance you’ll be putting on (and taking off) composition shingles.”
Asphalt shingles are easy to find in Dallas. They come in a wide variety of colors and styles. Many DFW homeowners opt for simple 3-tab shingles due to their lower cost. However, inexpensive shingles don't provide the same level of protection as more durable Class 4 shingles.
Asphalt shingles often come with 30-year warranties, but Dallas weather often shortens their lifespan.
Pros: Extremely popular and easy to find; generally low in cost; available in wide variety of styles and colors
Cons: Dallas weather often lowers asphalt's lifespan; less protection against hail and high winds; occasional mildew issues
Class 4 Shingles
Dallas homeowners who are concerned about extreme heat, high wind, hail and storm damage to their roofs often opt for more durable Class 4 shingles.
Class 4 shingles are subjected to extra testing and designed to withstand significant impact damage. They're expected to handle 1" hailstones and falling tree limbs without much issue.
However, that added protection comes at a cost. Class 4 shingles are 20% more expensive than regular asphalt shingles. If the protection is worth the cost to you, HOMR's featured providers like IKO and Owens Corning brands.
Pros: Increased protection against Dallas weather; less prone to impact damage from hail and trees; reduces roof repair service needs over time
Cons: Up to 20% more expensive than asphalt shingles; upgrades aren't usually covered by insurance
Interested in FORTIFIED roofing status? This special designation involves upgraded roof protection (like Class 4 Shingles) and offers tax and financial incentives to Dallas area homeowners. Read more in the HOMR Guide to FORTIFIED Roofing.
Metal Roofing
Wikideas1, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons
“A metal roof in Dallas is all about the thickness and finish,” Travis Jones explains. “We don't go any thinner than 24 gauge in DFW, and we use a coating and finish that protects against hail and storm damage.”
Metal roofs can last up to 50 years in Dallas Fort Worth. They're lightweight and durable, and some clients report a decrease in their monthly energy bills after installing a metal roof.
Be sure to use the proper protective coat on your metal roof. An uncoated metal roof leads to chipped paint — hail won't rip apart your roof, but those little chips can lead to rust issues.
Buyer beware: Some insurance companies do not cover hail or storm damage to metal roofs they deem to be cosmetic. You must prove the damage is functional to be covered.
Pros: Extremely durable against harsh Dallas weather conditions; easy to paint and finish to any color or style (matte/gloss/metallic); lightweight and easy to install
Cons: Occasional insurance coverage issues in the event of damage; susceptible to rust if uncoated
Concrete Tile and Clay Tile
Concrete tile and clay tile roofs are popular in many part of the United States. But are they right for Dallas homes?
Tile roofs provide beautiful, European-inspired design features. They're Class A fire resistant and are generally long-lasting materials.
However, the porous nature of concrete and clay tile can lead to mold and mildew issues. The underlying roof materials must be replaced after 15-20 years as a result. Also, concrete tiles weigh around 1,000 pounds per 100 square foot — that's a lot of weight resting on top of your home.
HOMR's featured roofing providers do not see much demand for concrete or clay roofing in Dallas for these reasons.
Pros: Distinctive style with European flair; generally long-lasting finish; fireproof material
Cons: Require a significant amount of upkeep and maintenance; extremely heavy material; underlying material must be replaced every 15-20 years
Conclusion
“Getting a new roof is a pain,” Travis Jones says. “But getting a new kitchen or living room because your roof caved in is a real pain. That's what we're trying to protect.”
Dallas weather can throw a lot at you at once. Hail and tree limbs cause roof damage. Strong winds and microbursts can tear up your shingle. Maintaining your roof here can get complicated.
That's why HOMR likes Dallas roofing companies that keep it simple. Ones that offer every roofing service possible, from installation to repair to maintenance.
Staying safe and dry under your roof should be as simple as one phone call. Make that call to HOMR 24/7 and schedule fast, fairly-priced service with our home management team.
Need roof repair and maintenance in Dallas now? Send us a message and get a free quote on the project.
